Category Archives: union

We’ve turned whistleblower!

Adrian Harris 2

Professor Adrian Harris, consultant medical oncologist at Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, addressing the meeting. © Peter McIntyre

The Oxford NUJ branch is blowing the whistle on NHS England for its lack of transparency and its attempts to frustrate efforts to hold it to account for its decision relating to the future of Oxfordshire’s diagnostic cancer scanning services.

The question we are asking is this:

Why is NHS England being so secretive about the basis for its decision regarding the future of Oxfordshire’s PET-CT diagnostic imaging services? What is the basis for its decision to take this service away from the world-class radiology team at the Churchill hospital, where it operates as an integrated part of a world-class cancer care service? Why has NHS England awarded preferred bidder status to a private company that operates from mobile units, and has no-one with a licence to administer the radioactive substances used in PET-CT?

This are questions that should normally be posed by reporters, and our local journalists are certainly doing their best to get answers. It is a question also for Oxfordshire’s Health Overview and Scrutiny Committee, which is empowered to ‘call-in’ questionable decisions made by our public healthcare services, and they too have been doing their best to get answers.

Our NUJ branch got involved because we are alarmed at the lengths to which NHS England seems to be prepared to go to avoid being scrutinised and held to account for this decision. It has not addressed questions of substance relating to the impact the change to the service will have on the quality and safety of patient care. It seems intent on stifling those who seek to voice their concerns, and withholding information that the public has a right to know.

The Oxford NUJ branch is saying that it is not OK for public bodies to hide behind legal threats, to seek to silence critics or to create a climate of fear in public bodies.

We took the unusual step of calling a public meeting in Oxford Town Hall to try to build up a picture of what is going on. We posted the speakers’ presentation on our YouTube channel. You can view the full playlist here. Video recordings are courtesy of Peter McIntyre.

What they said

We invited Professor Adrian Harris, a consultant medical oncologist at Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust, to tell us the story so far from the perspective of those currently running the service at the Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust (OUHT).

Adrian explained that the quality of PET-CT scans matters because they change treatment decision in up 40% of cases. Referring to correspondence from NHS England, he argue they had built their case on “incorrect data to force the issue to allow InHealth to come in and disrupt an outstanding service,” and that they were blocking access to key information by claiming there were “discussions” and a “legal review” that do not exist.

“NHS England have not told the truth, they have put legal pressure on doctors, they don’t reply to emails, when corrected in things they don’t respond and the role of Bruno [Dr Bruno Holthof is Chief Executive Officer of Oxford University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust] in not taking us through what the doctors say, what the Trust wants to do, passing on messages very worrying to me. We have to have an open access. How can we have an explanation, not only just from NHS England but the local Trust leaders as to why they are behaving like that?”

You can see his full presentation here (11 mins)

We also invited Tamsin Allen, a partner at Bindmans law firm who specialises in defamation law and has long experience representing whistleblowers, to comment on the legal issues.

Tamsin talked about the letter NHS England’s lawyers had sent to the OUHT, warning them that any statement that suggests that the result of awarding the contract to InHealth puts patient safety at risk or compromises the provision of cancer care and research in the health system “would be defamatory if repeated to any third party”.

“That’s an incredibly broad and sweeping claim, and it’s also legally wrong,” said Tamsin. She questioned a later clarification from NHS England that the letter had been intended as helpful advice regarding possible defamation suits from others, rather than a direct threat. “Lawyers are used to using language precisely particularly when talking about the law. That was a deliberate sentence. It’s an intimidating statement.”

You can view her presentation here (14 mins)

We also invited Seamus Dooley, the Assistant General Secretary of the NUJ, to talk about the role of a strong local press in championing the public interest by scrutinising the behaviour of those in charge of our public services.

“This is not about the law. This is about bullying and unacceptable behaviour. From the NUJ’s perspective, we are under no doubt that what this is intended is to have a chilling effect which inhibits debate and inhibits questions. It is about the use of law to close down debate. Does it mean journalists will stop asking questions? I hope not.”

You can view his presentation here (5 mins).

The meeting was chaired by Anna Wagstaff, Secretary of the Oxford and District NUJ branch. In her opening remarks she said, “This is behaviour you could maybe expect from a tobacco company but not from our health service. We’d like this to be a practical meeting focused on how we can bring some accountability and transparency to this process to ensure decision are made in the best interests of the public that the NHS is meant to serve.”

You can view her presentation here (2 mins)

You can see the Banbury Guardian’s report (26 June 2019) on their battle to get access to the relevant correspondence between NHS England and the Oxford University Hospitals NHS Trust here.

You can see the Oxford Mail report of the meeting here

Leave a comment

Filed under local news, Oxfordshire, public interest journalism, recent events, reporting, union

We’re having a pop-up Xmas party!

Xmas party 2018

Worried that print journalism is going down the tubes?

Concerned that the BBC may become an arm of the welfare state?

Upset that publishers have still not learnt the lessons from more than a decade of disastrous off-shoring?

Or just fancy spending an evening with other media workers?

We’re on it! 

Join us  for the Oxford NUJ Christmas pop up party! Meet colleagues and potential future colleagues, and help us set the media industry to rights over a pint or two…

Where? King’s Arms, opposite the Bodleian, top of Broad St, Oxford

When? Thursday 13th December, 7.15 onwards

Who? If you work in the media, you’re welcome

See you there

 

 

Leave a comment

Filed under union, upcoming events

Ideas for strengthening NUJ organisation in books and journals

bill mackeithHow can NUJ activists and organisers strengthen union organisation in  book & journal publishing, and achieve a stronger profile within the NUJ?

The following notes represent the results of conversations between members of the Oxford branch committee and the Taylor & Francis chapel committee. They formed the basis of a talk given by Bill MacKeith at the London Book Branch meeting, 11 October 2018. We encourage members working in the sector to take a look and to comment. We see greater collaboration as key, and hope this contribution can help open up an inclusive discussion.

You can leave a comment at the end, or contact us directly at oxfordnuj@gmail.com

NUJ Book Branch talk on Organising in Books, notes, 11 October 2018

Need for the best resources

Need for updated resources/campaign and tailored templates aimed at the books/journals sector on key issues:

  • recruitment,
  • improving pay
  • improving pensions
  • equality
  • gender pay gap
  • stress and workload/staffing levels
  • health and safety
  • maternity/paternity
  • mental health awareness

Find a collaborative way of addressing that, by at least having a central resource centre where campaign/recruitment materials that chapels have already prepared (e.g. the T&F leaflet on the gender pay gap) can be uploaded and accessed by others

Possibility of doing a cheap and cheerful recruitment video aimed at this sector – could be just people from different book/journal chapel saying why they joined, why they are glad they did etc.

A profile for academic publishing

Academic publishing should have much more of a profile within the NUJ, so it looks as if ‘the NUJ knows know academic publishing and the current issues’ in the way that we clearly know journalism. The content of this would need chapel input, particularly in terms of defining the big current professional issues and how they feed in to industrial issues (e.g. working out how the digitalisation of every aspect of publishing impacts on old recruitment divisions and also gender pay/status gaps; earlier examples include impact of Open Access on investment in editorial quality, and also impact of contracting out and race to the bottom on quality). Chapels need to define the issue, but it is up to the leadership and The Journalist (!) to give more visibility to them.

Building collaboration between our chapels

It’s all about building an effective collaboration around these issues between chapel committees in the sector (particularly within academic publishing). The new Books NEC members could be important in helping this happen. Also, important to build direct links with the Springer Nature chapel, and other active academic publishing chapels (like Lexis Nexis maybe?)

Publishing Alliance 

We should look into setting up some sort of (working title) ‘Publishing Alliance’ where all the active NUJ and also Unite book/journal chapels can campaign publicly on chosen issues (also with Society of Young Publishers/ Society of Freelance Editors and Proofreaders), maybe starting with the gender pay gap. Could be one way of building a profile for the NUJ in academic publishing.

Who can we recruit?

Who can and cannot join? This is a source of much friction and people see it as arbitrary, because a lot of sales and IT work involves making editorial-type judgements and understanding things from an editorial perspective. You cannot separate them. When commissioning editors attend book fairs, they are sales persons. We need to be more flexible with the interpretation of NUJ eligibility criteria. Would be good for book/journal chapels to suggest guidelines and see if they do or do not fit within the current rulebook. Alternatively propose a rule change.

A more secure and up to date way of handling membership information
[GDPR issues have since been addressed]

Present system is not GDPR compliant.

More important, an M/FoC should be able to welcome each new member in the Chapel into the NUJ community.

T&F Chapel has submitted evidence to Michelle Stanistreet on this.

Training

Absolutely essential to have a programme of NUJ education. Such a programme, according to the T&F MoC, has transformed the chapel, it has been inspirational, building confidence and boldness in the chapel and its officers and representatives.

T&F Chapel speak very highly of NUJ trainer Caroline Holmes, who has delivered training to some 8-11 NUJ reps at T&F.

Book Branch could organise a series of NUJ training sessions for book reps and M/FoCs in the London area.

Training courses could include courses on:

  • Running a Chapel
  • Running campaigns in your Chapel
  • representing members
  • negotiating
  • pensions etc.

Chapel organisation

  • T&F have monthly meetings
  • Training of reps central (see Training above).
  • Have appointed NUJ reps department by department.
  • T&F, in addition to the annual round of pay negotiations, organise around issues which they raise with management. They have task forces of members working on the following:
    • Equality and diversity
    • Stress and workload
    • Recruitment and communications
    • Pensions

Branch meetings

Locate for convenience of important groups of members
Time/day ditto
Time agenda to fit with Chapel reps/members not staying for whole meeting
Take Chapel reports early in agenda.

Magazine and Book Industrial Council

Responsible according to the NUJ rulebook for:

  • Overseeing industrial matters in the 2 sectors
  • Training
  • Oversight of the work of the servicing officers.

Big victory for Springer/Nature recognition.

Note some MABIC activities in the past: recruitment and bullying leaflets, pay and conditions Broadsheet with agreements in at least 30 Chapels, full oversight of claims and agreements

One way forward is closer working between workplace, Branch, MABIC and NEC members, and the full-time officials Fiona Swarbrick and a.n.other (replacement for second organiser in Magazine and Books needed).

Students

Among leaflets needed is one for potential student members that is books-specific that says Why You Should Join the NUJ/What’s in it for you?

Working with Unite

  • Experience varied: Penguin, Macmillan, Pearson, OUP experiences
  • Lessons from Penguin? Generally very good experience.

New media

Effective use of new media to be explored

BM 11.10.18

 

Bill’s background

  • Penguin 1970-75
  • Elsevier Publishing Projects/Phaidon/Musterlin 1976-90
  • p/t Macmillan Dictionary of Art, Economist Intelligence Unit 1990-94
  • freelance: OUP, Pearson, Routledge, Minority Rights Unit, etc.1994-

Union positions: ASTMS Publishing 516 Branch committee, ASTMS negotiating team at Penguin, 1971-5. Founding chair Oxford ASTMS Publishing branch 1976-8. Oxford NUJ branch member since 1978, chapel officer EPP and Musterlin 1985-91; MABIC member and sometimes chair 1980- ; Oxford branch or MABIC delegate to national delegate meeting, 1978- ; member and currently chair NUJ Appeals Tribunal 2008-

 

Leave a comment

Filed under publishing, union

DM – an experience of a first-time delegate

Branch member Lynn Degele shares her experience of attending DM for the first time.
Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under union

Supporting the UCU strike

Poster for UCU strike.

Our branch, which has many members working in academic publishing, has resolved to support the recent industrial action by the University and College Union (UCU). The NUJ has many other issues in common with UCU, such as the fight to defend academia against marketization, and we are hoping to have a speaker from the UCU at a branch meeting soon. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under union

Local reporter – a fantastic job and we do it well

Gill Oliver_1399 resized

Gill Oliver, business and property reporter

This comment piece is entirely my own personal view and not that of the Oxford Mail, The Oxford Times, or any other journalists there, nor of Newsquest or Gannett.

I KEEP hearing and reading scathing descriptions about how terrible regional and local newspapers have become.

It’s a sad truth that many UK local titles have been axed or reduced to a shell of their former selves and that is a tragedy and a scandal.

But as we mark Local News Matters week, please don’t tar all regional and local newspapers with the same brush. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under union

Join us Dec 13th to talk media and migrants over mulled wine

mulled-wine-shutter-stockJoin us, Tuesday December 13th, for an evening of friendship, mulled wine and mince pies, where we will turn our attention to groups who feel increasingly excluded, vulnerable and friendless in today’s Britain. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under branch meetings, newspapers, Oxfordshire, quality, reporting, union, upcoming events

Stuck in the doldrums: notes from a freelance editor

Drawing of a person sitting in a huge rut in the ground.IT IS NOT just newspaper publishers that are cutting costs and seeing quality drop: this is becoming prevalent across many sectors within the NUJ. A branch member with long experience in educational publishing reports on the issues facing freelance editors. Continue reading

Leave a comment

Filed under editing, freelance, publishing, quality, union

South London colleagues warn of Newsquest’s kamikaze plans

parliament-pic

How can 12 journalists produce 11 local papers and 8 websites? Last week, the journalists at Newsquest’s South London titles got a feel for how when, after a week on strike, they returned to work for a few days before walking out again for another week.

Speaking at a meeting called by the Oxford branch at The Punter last Thursday, one chapel rep described the process. “You just have to get the paper out: Do we have the age of this girl? No? Do we have a name for her? No? F*** it! That’ll do. Off it goes.” Continue reading

1 Comment

Filed under newspapers, quality, reporting, union

Dreaming Spires branch Inspires

digitally-converged-summer-social

More than 60 journalist from every sector came to Oxford NUJ branch’s ‘digitally-converged summer social’.

Those attending included a sizeable contingent from BBC Oxford – whose chapel co-organised the event – on-screen reporters from Meridan TV’s newsroom, Chapel representatives from the Oxford Mail and Oxford Guardian and members working in book publishing.

Anna Wagstaff, branch secretary, explained the thinking behind the event:  “Our local media is interlinked. And in this fast-changing media sector, we all have an interest in fostering a local media ecosystem that offers opportunities to earn a decent living, doing whatever we do to the best of our ability. We wanted to bring together the broadest possible range of members to start to explore common areas of interest.”

The energy generated by the event – which was held in an arts centre near BBC Oxford – was palpable.  Alison Campbell, a Banbury-based PR said: “I can’t believe it when I meet PRs who aren’t in the NUJ – this event is another example of how relevant the NUJ is to us”.  Several others at the event were equally committed to building NUJ membership.

Paul Jenner, BBC Oxford FOC, said: “I was delighted at the wide range of people who came to the social, and as a result we have had several new membership enquiries. We truly are stronger when we work together.”

NUJ president, Tim Dawson, who was invited to the event to speak, later described the social as one of the best NUJ branch meetings he had ever attended.  “The plan to bring people together from every sector really worked.  The mix of people made for an enormously stimulating event – if other branches could emulate this success it would be an enormous boost to the entire union,” he said.

Cross-posted from the nuj.org.uk

Leave a comment

Filed under broadcasting, digital, freelance, newspapers, Oxfordshire, recent events, union